Can Regional Connectivity Projects Overcome the Middle East’s Security Deficit?

As geopolitical rivalries and security threats deepen regional fragmentation, emerging infrastructure projects could offer an alternative path toward cooperation. By strengthening regional agency, building trust, and establishing shared rules, connectivity could help lay the foundations for a more stable Middle Eastern order.

November 22, 2026
Mehmet Ilhanli

The Middle East is no longer what it once was. The old order is now gone, and the new one is yet to emerge. However, two major shifts in regional geopolitics and geoeconomics will determine whether the new order leads to cooperation or further fragmentation.

On the one hand, recent attacks on Saudi Arabia by Yemen’s Ansar Allah—widely known as the Houthis— have further intensified the growing security concerns across the region. Since Israel’s war on Gaza after October 7, 2023, the Middle East has witnessed a drastic shift in regional threat perceptions and strategic realignments. This change has been exacerbated by U.S.-Israel attacks on Iran and Iran’s subsequent targeting of several Gulf countries in the region. States have responded to this volatile environment by building new small-scale military alliances, such as the Mecca and Badr Defense Pacts, to mitigate developing threats and risks.

Against this backdrop, an emerging connectivity landscape is also materializing through transnational geoeconomic initiatives, such as large-scale infrastructure projects being developed and invested in by a growing number of countries. Türkiye’s efforts to revive the Hejaz Railway running from Istanbul to Medina, Iraq’s Development Road, China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC), the recently announced Europe-Egypt-Neom-Gulf Cooperation Multimodal Corridor, and the Kirkuk-Banyas pipeline between Iraq and Syria all reflect a broader ambition of leveraging their geographies for economic benefit.

These two multilateral developments are usually discussed separately because they represent different political, economic, and spatial visions at the regional level. In one respect, security is treated as a question of geopolitics and zero-sum competition, military capabilities, and strategic alliances. Conversely, connectivity is understood through geoeconomics and positive-sum situations, trade cooperation, and development. Even when considered together, security is presented as a condition for a more connected region, since the success of connectivity largely depends on it. Yet this relationship may work in the opposite direction. If planned well, connectivity itself can help create a more secure regional order.

This is because current regional geopolitics limits a region-wide security framework, as it has been defined by protracted violent conflicts along ethnic, sectarian, and religious divisions and a high level of dependence on external powers. This has intensified recently, driving further fragmentation and disorder.

Connectivity, by contrast, can help create a new regional order by strengthening dialogue, enhancing cooperation, and deepening interdependence. Large-scale infrastructure projects can provide a material foundation for this order by supporting regional states building agency, trust, and norms, which are essential for a predictable and stable regional order.

 

Strengthening Collective and Individual Capacity Through Agency-Building

Regional geopolitics in the Middle East has long been defined by the political and economic interests of external powers, which have shaped the regional order through extensive interventions. This also manifests itself in externally driven connectivity initiatives such as BRI and IMEC, which aim to reshape the global and regional political economy by linking world regions through ports, railways, ships, roads, and pipelines. This has undermined regional states’ capacity to assert agency and act collectively for mutual interests.

However, if the new order is envisioned as reflecting regional states’ interests and aspirations, the first condition will be agency and a claim of ownership. In this regard, connectivity can support agency-building in different ways. First, it can enable agent states to shape their vision aligned with local needs and interests. These shared interests can then become a platform for building capacity to find region-specific solutions to regional problems and, ultimately, to act collectively in response to regional developments.

Indeed, Iraq’s Development Road Project could be a good example of agency-building through connectivity. Unlike the BRI and IMEC, the project reinforces local agency by bringing together Iraq, Türkiye, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates. It aims to connect the Gulf to Europe and reflect the priorities and ambitions of these states. In this regard, the project has significant implications for regional ownership and agency building, with the potential to foster broader regional participation over time.

 

Fostering Interaction and Building Trust

In an era of globalization, states are deeply interconnected. This interconnectedness compels them to work at regional and global levels with fellow states despite disputes over political matters. A certain level of trust is essential for building a more stable and predictable regional order. Nevertheless, longstanding conflicts, geopolitical rivalries, and disputed territories have resulted in low levels of trust among Middle Eastern states, as the current episode of conflict between Gulf countries and Iran illustrates well. In these circumstances, developing a new order through a security-oriented regional framework is difficult, as states do not trust one another, take countermeasures against each other, escalate, and fall into conflict.

In such moments, connectivity can help (re-)build trust among Middle Eastern countries by creating a platform for regular interaction, shared interests, and fulfilling commitments. In fact, hard infrastructure such as transborder railways, roads, and pipelines can create conditions for dialogue before political trust exists, because implementing these projects requires regular interaction. This can gradually increase interdependence and bring states together around shared interests and economic benefits.

A recent example is the Kirkuk-Baniyas pipeline between Iraq and Syria. The pipeline, which faced intermittent disruptions due to political conflicts, is now on the agenda of both governments following the fall of the Assad regime in 2024. In a recent interview with the Iraqi News Agency, Syrian President Ahmad Al-Sharaa said the two countries should assert their sovereignty and be masters of their own decisions, deepening their political and economic relations independent of external influence. In this context, reviving cross-border infrastructure projects such as the Kirkuk–Baniyas pipeline has enormous potential to realize this political vision by fostering shared economic interests, strengthening bilateral cooperation, and building mutual trust through transborder infrastructure.

 

Defining Rules of the Game

Connectivity is intentional. When states connect, they assert that they are trustworthy and can trust the other. But this is not enough. Participating states should agree on rules of the game because infrastructure projects necessitate rules governing customs, financial modes, technical procedures and standards that facilitate the flow of goods and people. Without rules that maintain the flow, cooperation easily becomes vulnerable to political change and elite interests.

Rules can eventually develop into norms that unite regional states and form institutions that foster closer cooperation in mutual interest. Indeed, regional governments have signed various memorandums of understanding on infrastructure projects, but they lack a region-wide connectivity framework. In this context, the Association of Southeast Asian Nations’ (ASEAN) Connectivity Strategic Plan could present a model. Although political and economic conditions differ across the regions, Middle Eastern countries can use ASEAN’s approach for developing region-specific rules that may establish a normative and institutional framework for a new regional order.

 

Conclusion

What defines an order are relations. States interact under rules that reinforce stability, predictability, and sustainability. This is not the case in recent regional politics in the Middle East, which has been facing security challenges stemming from geopolitical rivalries, external interventions, and ethnic-sectarian-religious divisions. This makes it harder to build a stable regional order, since security concerns are central to it.

In such a situation, connectivity can provide the political and economic basis for a new regional order by creating concrete spaces where actors can work together. Connections built through infrastructure and forged around shared interests can help regional states de-link from external aspirations and define regional priorities and interests. It can also strengthen and expand regional actors’ capacity. Collectively, regular interaction can make mutual expectations more predictable, and the rules that facilitate this cooperation may, over time, form the foundation for broader regional norms and institutions.

What the Middle East needs urgently today is not a grand political settlement to create a new regional order. Rather, it needs incremental steps that gradually strengthen regional states’ decision-making capacity, foster mutual trust despite political disputes, and create shared rules. Emerging connectivity initiatives across the region could advance these objectives and lay the groundwork for a cooperative regional order.

 

 

 

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Middle East Council on Global Affairs.

Issue: Regional Relations
Country:

Writer

National University of Singapore
Mehmet İlhanlı is a joint PhD researcher in Geography at the National University of Singapore (NUS) and King’s College London from 2025 to 2029, focusing on critical geopolitics, economic corridors, and youth in peace and conflict.